Discover the Controversial Hand Pass Rule in Hockey and How it Changed the Game Forever


Sharing is Caring


For hockey enthusiasts, there’s nothing quite as exciting as watching a game live. From the roar of the crowd to the sound of blades gliding across the ice, there’s a certain thrill that comes with being in the stands or watching from home. But what happens when the game is changed by a controversial rule? Enter the hand pass rule in hockey.

First introduced in the early 1900s, the hand pass rule was designed to prevent players from using their hands to advance the puck. But over the years, the rule has evolved, becoming one of the most debated and contentious in the sport. From the infamous 2019 playoffs incident to its impact on gameplay, discover everything you need to know about the controversial hand pass rule in hockey.

So, whether you’re a seasoned fan or just getting into the sport, join us as we explore the history, controversy, and future of one of the most talked-about rules in hockey. Strap on your skates, grab your stick, and get ready to hit the ice as we dive into the world of the hand pass in hockey.

But hold on tight, because this isn’t just any ordinary article. We’ll take you on a deep dive into the hand pass rule, revealing insider secrets, and unknown facts about how the rule has changed the game forever. So sit back, relax, and get ready to learn something new about one of the most controversial rules in hockey.

What is the Hand Pass Rule in Hockey?

The hand pass rule is a fundamental aspect of ice hockey that prohibits players from passing the puck with their hands. The rule is designed to keep the game fair and safe, and it has been in place for many years. The hand pass rule is a source of controversy and confusion in the hockey world, and it has been the subject of much debate over the years.

In general, the hand pass rule is simple: if a player uses their hand to pass the puck to a teammate, the play is stopped, and a faceoff is awarded in the offending team’s defensive zone. However, there are many exceptions and nuances to this rule, and it can be difficult for even the most seasoned hockey fans to keep up with all the details.

Exceptions to the Hand Pass Rule

While the hand pass rule generally prohibits players from using their hands to pass the puck, there are a few key exceptions that are important to understand. These exceptions include:

  • A player is allowed to use their hand to knock the puck down to the ice, but they must then play the puck with their stick before any other player can touch it.
  • A player is allowed to use their hand to bat the puck out of the air, but they must not close their hand on the puck or throw it towards a teammate.
  • A player is allowed to use their hand to catch a deflected puck, but they must then immediately drop it to the ice before playing it with their stick.

The Evolution of the Hand Pass Rule

The hand pass rule has undergone several changes over the years, reflecting the evolution of the game and the changing attitudes of hockey officials. For example, prior to 1949, players were allowed to use their hand to bat the puck down, catch it, and pass it to a teammate. In 1949, the NHL banned all hand passes in the offensive zone, and in 1967, the rule was extended to the entire rink.

Since then, there have been several adjustments to the hand pass rule, including the addition of the exceptions outlined above. Today, the hand pass rule remains a critical aspect of hockey, and it continues to be a source of discussion and debate among fans and experts alike.

The Importance of Understanding the Hand Pass Rule

As a hockey fan, it’s important to have a clear understanding of the hand pass rule and its exceptions. This knowledge will allow you to better appreciate the game, understand the decisions made by officials on the ice, and engage in informed discussions with other fans. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran of the game or a newcomer looking to learn more, taking the time to understand the hand pass rule is a crucial step towards becoming a true hockey aficionado.

The Infamous Incident: The Impact of the Hand Pass in the 2019 Playoffs

In May 2019, the San Jose Sharks were facing off against the St. Louis Blues in Game 3 of the Western Conference Finals. With the score tied 4-4 in overtime, Sharks forward Timo Meier made a blatant hand pass to teammate Gustav Nyquist who then passed the puck to Erik Karlsson, who scored the game-winning goal.

The play immediately caused controversy and outrage from the Blues and their fans, as the officials missed the clear hand pass violation. The league admitted the error after the game and publicly apologized to the Blues, but the damage had been done. The Sharks went on to win the series, but the hand pass incident left a lasting impact on the game and the league’s officiating.

The Outcry and Aftermath

The hand pass incident sparked a heated debate among hockey fans and analysts. Some argued that the officials should have caught the violation, while others criticized the league’s replay review system for not allowing the officials to review the play.

The incident also led to a renewed emphasis on the NHL’s rules and officiating, with calls for increased technology and resources to help officials make more accurate calls.

The Rule Change

As a result of the hand pass incident, the NHL made a significant change to the hand pass rule for the 2019-2020 season. Previously, hand passes were only allowed in the defensive zone and were not allowed in the offensive zone or the neutral zone. Under the new rule, all hand passes are illegal, regardless of where they occur on the ice.

This change was intended to make the rule more consistent and easier to enforce for officials, but it also had the potential to change the way the game is played. Teams would no longer be able to use hand passes to start a rush up the ice, for example.

The Legacy of the Hand Pass Incident

The hand pass incident will forever be remembered as a controversial moment in hockey history, but it also had a significant impact on the game. The outcry and aftermath of the incident sparked important discussions about the NHL’s rules and officiating, ultimately leading to a rule change that could have a lasting impact on the game.

Despite the controversy, the hand pass incident also demonstrated the passion and intensity of the sport and its fans. It is moments like these that make hockey so thrilling to watch and why the game will always hold a special place in the hearts of fans around the world.

Why is the Hand Pass Rule so Controversial?

Of all the rules in hockey, the hand pass rule is one of the most controversial. This is because it can be difficult to interpret and enforce, leading to disagreements among players, coaches, and fans alike.

The rule itself is fairly simple: players cannot use their hands to pass the puck to a teammate in the offensive zone. If a player does make a hand pass, play is stopped and the ensuing faceoff takes place in the offending team’s defensive zone.

The Impact on Gameplay

  • The hand pass rule can have a significant impact on the flow of gameplay. Players must be careful not to accidentally make a hand pass, which can break up a potentially game-changing play.
  • Additionally, the rule can be difficult for officials to enforce in real time, leading to missed calls and controversy on the ice.

The Role of Video Review

With the advent of video review in hockey, the hand pass rule has become even more contentious. Fans and players alike have criticized the league’s use of video review to make calls related to hand passes, arguing that it disrupts the flow of the game and takes too long to make a decision.

The Importance of Consistency

  • Another source of controversy surrounding the hand pass rule is the lack of consistency in its enforcement. Some officials may be more lenient or strict when calling hand passes, leading to confusion among players and fans alike.
  • Many argue that the league needs to do a better job of clarifying the rule and ensuring that it is enforced consistently across all games and officials.

The Evolution of the Hand Pass Rule in Hockey

Hockey is a sport that has undergone many changes throughout its history, and one of the most controversial areas is the hand pass rule. The rule has evolved significantly over time, with the aim of balancing safety concerns and maintaining the excitement of the game.

Before the 1920s, players were not allowed to pass the puck with their hands at any time. However, this was changed in 1927, allowing players to make hand passes in the defensive zone. In 1943, the rule was further relaxed, allowing hand passes in all zones if the passer and the receiver were on the same team.

1949 – 1995: The No-Touch Hand Pass Rule

  • From 1949 to 1995, the no-touch hand pass rule was in effect. This meant that players were not allowed to touch the puck with their hands at any time, including in the defensive zone.
  • The main aim of this rule was to encourage more passing with sticks and reduce the risk of injury from high sticks and slashes. However, it also made the game slower and less exciting, as players had to spend more time controlling the puck with their sticks.

1995 – 2006: The Hybrid Hand Pass Rule

  • In 1995, the NHL introduced a hybrid hand pass rule, allowing hand passes in the defensive zone but penalizing offensive players for making hand passes in the offensive zone.
  • This rule aimed to encourage more creativity and faster play in the neutral and offensive zones, while still maintaining safety concerns in the defensive zone.

2006 – Present: The Current Hand Pass Rule

  • The current hand pass rule, which has been in place since 2006, allows hand passes only in the defensive zone, and only if the passer and the receiver are both inside the defensive zone.
  • The rule also allows hand passes from a player’s defensive zone to the neutral zone, but only if the puck does not cross the red line.

Overall, the evolution of the hand pass rule in hockey has been driven by a desire to balance safety concerns with the excitement and creativity of the game. While the rule has undergone significant changes over time, it remains a controversial area of the sport, with fans and players alike debating the merits of different approaches.

How Do Referees Determine a Hand Pass in Hockey?

Hand passes in hockey can be tricky for referees to determine, and it’s not always clear-cut. In most cases, a hand pass occurs when a player uses their hand to bat the puck to a teammate. However, there are a few different scenarios that can arise, and referees have to use their judgment to make the right call.

One thing referees look for is whether the hand pass was intentional or accidental. If a player clearly uses their hand to direct the puck to a teammate, that’s an intentional hand pass and will result in a stoppage of play. However, if the player simply deflects the puck with their hand in the course of trying to make a play, that may be ruled an accidental hand pass and play will continue.

Factors That Can Impact Referee Decisions

  • Player Positioning: Referees will consider where the player was on the ice and whether they had a clear view of the puck when making the hand pass.
  • Puck Trajectory: Referees will look at the direction the puck was going and whether the hand pass altered its path or intended destination.
  • Game Situation: Referees may take into account the score, time remaining in the game, and other factors when making a hand pass call.

Challenges in Making Hand Pass Calls

One of the biggest challenges for referees is the speed of the game. Hockey is a fast-paced sport, and hand passes can happen in a split second. Referees have to make quick decisions based on what they see and interpret the rules correctly. Additionally, the location of the play can also be a challenge, as referees may have obstructed views or be out of position to see a hand pass.

Despite these challenges, referees are trained to make the best possible call in each situation. Hand pass calls may be controversial at times, but ultimately, the goal is to ensure fair play and maintain the integrity of the game.

Hand Pass Rule in Other Sports: A Comparison

The hand pass rule is not exclusive to ice hockey, as many other sports have similar rules to limit the use of hands and ensure a fair play environment. One of the most popular sports that shares this rule with hockey is soccer. In soccer, a handball is called when a player touches the ball with their hand or arm intentionally, regardless of the position of their body or the proximity of the ball. The exception to this rule is when the goalkeeper uses their hands within their designated area.

Another sport that implements a similar rule is basketball. In basketball, players are not allowed to touch the ball with their hands or arms while it’s still in play, except for the designated ball-handler. The ball can be passed from player to player using a variety of other techniques such as dribbling, passing, and shooting, but any contact with the ball made by a player’s hands or arms, other than the ball-handler, is considered a violation.

Hand Pass Rule in American Football

  • In American football, there are restrictions on how and when a pass can be thrown.
  • The ball must be thrown forward and cannot be thrown by a player whose feet are beyond the line of scrimmage.
  • If a player, other than the quarterback, throws a forward pass, the ball must be touched by another player before it’s caught, or it will result in a penalty.

Hand Pass Rule in Volleyball

In volleyball, the hand pass rule is called the double hit rule. This rule states that a player is not allowed to hit the ball twice in a row, unless the ball is hit off of an opponent’s block. This rule applies to both indoor and beach volleyball.

Hand Pass Rule in Rugby

  • In rugby, players can only pass the ball backward or sideways using their hands.
  • If a player accidentally passes the ball forward with their hands, it results in a penalty called a “knock-on.”
  • If a player intentionally passes the ball forward with their hands, it results in a scrum for the opposing team.

The Future of the Hand Pass Rule in Hockey

Hockey has seen its fair share of changes in rules and regulations over the years, and the hand pass rule is no exception. The rule has been implemented to prevent players from gaining an unfair advantage by passing the puck with their hands. But what does the future hold for this rule in hockey?

While there is no definitive answer, one can speculate about what the future may hold for the hand pass rule. The NHL may choose to enforce the rule more strictly, or they may choose to modify it to better suit the modern game. Another possibility is that advancements in technology may allow for more accurate detection of hand passes, leading to more consistent enforcement of the rule.

Stricter Enforcement of the Rule

  • If the NHL chooses to enforce the hand pass rule more strictly, it could lead to a significant decrease in the number of hand passes made during games. This would require a greater level of scrutiny by officials, and potentially lead to an increase in penalties being called for violations of the rule.
  • However, this could also result in more stoppages in play, and could potentially slow the game down.

Modification of the Rule

  • Another possibility for the future of the hand pass rule is that it may be modified to better suit the modern game. For example, the NHL could consider allowing hand passes in certain situations, such as when a player is defending themselves or their teammate from an incoming puck.
  • Alternatively, the NHL could consider making the rule stricter in certain areas of the rink, such as in the offensive zone or near the net, where hand passes are more likely to result in scoring chances.

Advancements in Technology

  • Advancements in technology may allow for more accurate detection of hand passes, leading to more consistent enforcement of the rule. For example, video replay could be used to determine whether or not a hand pass was made, and officials could be provided with better angles and more tools to make these determinations.
  • However, this could also lead to more controversy and debate over the interpretation of the rule, as different angles and perspectives may lead to different conclusions about whether or not a hand pass was made.

Ultimately, the future of the hand pass rule in hockey remains uncertain. However, by exploring the possibilities of stricter enforcement, modification, and advancements in technology, we can begin to understand the potential directions the rule may take in the coming years.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the hand pass rule in hockey?

The hand pass rule in hockey prohibits players from intentionally passing the puck to a teammate using their hand or arm. If a player passes the puck with their hand or arm, a whistle is blown and the opposing team is awarded a faceoff in the offending team’s zone. Hand pass and intentionally are the key phrases in this question.

Can a player catch the puck in hockey?

Yes, a player can catch the puck in hockey, but they are not allowed to hold onto it for an extended period of time. A player can only catch the puck and immediately drop it to the ice or bat it with their stick. Catching the puck and holding onto it results in a whistle and a faceoff. Catch and hold onto it are the key phrases in this question.

When can a player hand pass the puck in hockey?

There are only a few circumstances in which a player can legally hand pass the puck in hockey. For example, if a player in their defending zone passes the puck with their hand to a teammate who is also in the defending zone, it is not considered a hand pass. Additionally, if a referee signals a hand pass, players are allowed to bat the puck with their hand to a teammate. Legally and referee signals are the key phrases in this question.

Is a hand pass considered an infraction in all levels of hockey?

Yes, the hand pass rule is enforced in all levels of hockey, from amateur to professional. This rule is in place to prevent unfair advantages that could arise from the use of hands and to promote a fair and equal playing field. Infraction and enforced are the key phrases in this question.

Can a goalie hand pass the puck in hockey?

Yes, a goalie is allowed to hand pass the puck in their designated area behind the net, but they are not allowed to do so in any other part of the ice. If a goalie hand passes the puck outside of their designated area, it is considered an infraction and a whistle is blown. Goalie and designated area are the key phrases in this question.

What happens if a player accidentally hand passes the puck in hockey?

If a player accidentally hand passes the puck in hockey, the play continues as normal. The hand pass rule only applies to intentional passes made with the hand or arm. However, if a player hand passes the puck and a teammate subsequently scores a goal, the goal is disallowed and a faceoff is awarded in the offending team’s zone. Accidentally and intentional are the key phrases in this question.

Craving More Content?

Ice Hockey Central