Why Do They Pull The Goalie In Hockey? Find Out the Strategy Behind It


Sharing is Caring


Have you ever wondered why hockey teams pull their goalies when they are losing in the final minutes of a game? This is not just a desperate move to try and tie the game, but rather a strategic decision that can increase a team’s chances of winning.

The pulling of the goalie creates an extra attacker on the ice for the offensive team, increasing their chances of scoring. However, it also comes with risks, such as the opposing team scoring into the empty net. So why do teams take this calculated risk?

In this article, we will delve deeper into the strategy behind pulling the goalie in hockey. We will examine factors such as the score, time left in the game, strength of the opposition, and momentum shifts that influence this decision. Understanding these factors can give fans and players alike a greater appreciation for this bold and often debated tactic.

“Pulling the goalie is like playing poker โ€“ sometimes you need to go all-in to have a chance at winning.” -Dan Bylsma

We will also explore some memorable moments in NHL history when coaches made the call to pull the goalie, both successfully and unsuccessfully. From miraculous comebacks to heartbreaking losses, the decision to pull the goalie has made for some unforgettable moments in hockey.

By the end of this article, you will see that there is much more to pulling the goalie than meets the eye. Whether you’re a casual fan or a die-hard enthusiast, understanding this tactic is essential to fully appreciating the intricacies of the sport.

The Basics of Pulling the Goalie in Hockey

In hockey, a team might pull their goalie out of the net and bring in an extra skater during gameplay. This move is known as “pulling the goalie”. But why do they do this?

What Does it Mean to Pull the Goalie?

Pulling the goalie means that the goaltender is removed from the ice and replaced with a forward or defenseman player, giving the team six players on the ice instead of the usual five.

This bold move by a coach usually happens when a team is trailing late in the game. By removing the goalie, the team has a better chance of scoring a goal since there’s one extra attacking player on the ice.

“Itโ€™s just something you feel,” said Tampa Bay Lightning head coach Jon Cooper. “You have to get within your own soul whether you think pulling him at the time can change momentum.”

A team will only pull their goalie if they are down by one goal or tied, but time is running low – usually with under two minutes left in regulation play. In some cases, teams might also pull their goalie early, depending on how much time remains and how desperate the situation is. However, this carries more risk because the opposing team could easily score into the empty net without anyone defending it.

When is Pulling the Goalie Appropriate?

Knowing when to pull the goalie requires careful consideration by coaches. There needs to be enough time for the strategy to work, so it usually only happens late in the third period, when the team that’s behind needs to tie the game or is only down by one and wants to go ahead.

The decision to pull the goalie isn’t always about tying the game, though. Coaches also might use it as a desperate measure to change the momentum of their team, especially if they’re struggling with possession and need a scoring chance before time runs out.

“Oftentimes, you hear people say itโ€™s a desperation move,” Detroit Red Wings head coach Jeff Blashill said. “It absolutely is – but what weโ€™re really trying to do is give ourselves a 6-on-5 advantage.”

Although risky, pulling the goalie can sometimes be successful and make for an exciting finish. There are plenty of instances where teams have pulled off a come-from-behind win using this strategy.

One such example happened during the playoff final in the IIHF World U20. In the dying seconds of the third period, Finland’s goal was empty, and Kasperi Kapanen scored the game-tying goal, which led to overtime. Kasperi then went on to net another critical goal to lift Finland to victory over Russia.

Pulling the goalie can be a high-risk, high-reward decision by coaches, requiring careful consideration based on the situation. While it’s not always a guarantee that it will work, it provides an extra player on the ice, improves the chances of scoring a goal, and can turn the game around when done at the right time.

Understanding the Importance of Time and Score

Ice hockey is one of the most exciting sports around the world. One of the most thrilling moments in a game is when the losing team pulls its goalie in order to get an extra attacker on the ice. It’s an all-or-nothing move that emphasizes how important time and score can be in this sport.

This article will go into detail about why time and score matter in ice hockey, and how they affect the decision to pull the goalie.

Why Time and Score Matter

The importance of time and score cannot be overstated in the sport of ice hockey. Unlike other sports where you have plenty of time to come back from a deficit, in ice hockey, time is limited and every second counts. The team that is leading has the advantage of being able to play more conservatively and simply trying to run out the clock. This puts pressure on the trailing team to try and even things up quickly.

Another reason why time and score are so important is because penalties in ice hockey tend to be much longer than those in other sports. If a player commits a major penalty, they may be sent off for five minutes or more, leaving their team shorthanded and without the ability to replace that player until the penalty expires. In these situations, a goal scored by the opposing team would result in two points when it typically only results in one.

“When pulling your goaltender, the odds of scoring greatly increase while the odds of getting scored against also significantly increase.” -Brent Sutter

The data backs up the importance placed on time in hockey games. According to NHL.com, “teams trailing after the first period win just 19 percent of the time. Teams trailing after two periods win less than 10 percent of the time.” Teams simply do not have as much room for error in ice hockey and must make every moment count if they want to stay competitive.

How Time and Score Affect the Decision to Pull the Goalie

The decision to pull the goalie is always a high-risk move. It opens up an opportunity for the opposing team to score, but it also presents the trailing team with a chance to score and potentially tie or win the game. Two key factors that go into this decision are the amount of time left on the clock and the score differential.

If there is little time left in the game and the trailing team is down by two goals or more, pulling the goalie is essential. There simply isn’t enough time left to mount a comeback without the extra attacker. However, if there is a significant amount of time left on the clock (e.g., ten minutes or more), then coaches may be hesitant to pull the goalie too early since doing so could put their team at risk of conceding more goals.

Another factor that determines whether or not the goalie gets pulled is the score. If the game is tied, or if the trailing team is only down by one goal, then pulling the goalie becomes even more tempting. Coaches will often take calculated risks in these situations since the reward is worth the gamble.

“The further you get behind, the more likely that we might just try something different like pulling our goaltender sooner than later to see if we can create some momentum at the end of the game.” -Mike Babcock

The final factor that goes into the decision to pull the goalie comes down to the specific lineup that the team is running. If the number one line is on the ice and the opposing team is getting tired, then pulling the goalie could result in a quick flurry of shots and potentially a goal. Coaches may also pull the goalie if there is a faceoff in the opposing team’s zone, giving them an immediate opportunity to create a scoring chance.

Ice hockey is a high-intensity sport that requires teams to make strategic decisions based on time and score. Pulling the goalie is just one example of how coaches use these variables to try and gain an advantage on the ice. While it can be a risky move, it is sometimes necessary in order to give the team a fighting chance at victory.

How Coaches Determine When to Pull the Goalie

The Role of Analytics in Decision Making

In recent years, analytics has become a crucial component in hockey decision-making. Teams and coaches now have access to advanced statistics that can help them make informed decisions about when to pull their goalie during games.

Advanced goaltending metrics such as save percentage in close or high-danger situations, goals saved above average (GSAA), and expected goals against (xGA) have given coaches new insights into their goaliesโ€™ performances. By assessing these metrics alongside game situation data such as time remaining, score, skater strength, shot attempts, and scoring chances, coaches can better determine whether pulling the goalie is necessary or if there are other strategic options available.

“The numbers give you an answer of where your team sits and whatโ€™s going on,” said New Jersey Devils head coach Lindy Ruff. “Those things really come into play at certain times.”

Factors Considered When Deciding to Pull the Goalie

While advanced analytics play an important role in determining when to pull the goalie, factors specific to each game must also be considered by coaches. Generally, the decision to pull the goalie comes down to two main considerations: the score and the time remaining in the game.

When trailing late in a game, pulling the goalie gives teams an extra attacker on the ice, increasing their chances of scoring a game-tying or game-winning goal. However, this tactical decision can backfire if the opposing team scores an empty-netter while the goalie is off the ice, effectively ending any chance for a comeback.

Coaches must weigh the risk-reward factor when considering pulling the goalie – how much do they stand to gain versus the possible negative outcome? Other game-specific factors that coaches may consider include the opposing teamโ€™s offensive ability, how well their own team has been playing in the game thus far, and whether there is a critical faceoff in the near future.

“Itโ€™s all situational, itโ€™s not just one simple thing,” said Vancouver Canucks head coach Travis Green. “I think you go on feel sometimes too.”

Coaches must balance both analytical insights and game-specific factors when deciding whether to pull the goalie. It is a high-stakes decision that can significantly impact the outcome of the game – something that NHL coaches take very seriously.

The Risks and Rewards of Pulling the Goalie

Why do they pull the goalie in hockey? This is a common question among sports enthusiasts, especially those who are new to the game. To put it simply, pulling the goalie is a strategy used by coaches when their team is trailing near the end of the game.

The Potential Benefits of Pulling the Goalie

There are several potential benefits of pulling the goalie:

  • Extra Player: By removing the goaltender from the ice, the coach adds an extra player to the offensive lineup. This gives the team a better chance of scoring a goal and potentially tying or winning the game.
  • Momentum Shift: A successful goal can change the momentum of the game and boost the morale of the players on the trailing team. This increased confidence may lead to more aggressive play and additional goals.
  • Last Resort: In some cases, pulling the goalie may be seen as a last resort for a team that desperately needs to win. It shows the other team and the fans that the coach is willing to take risks to achieve victory.

The Risks Involved with Pulling the Goalie

There are also significant risks involved with pulling the goalie, including:

  • Empty Net Goals: With no goaltender protecting the net, the opposing team has a much easier time scoring empty net goals. If the goaltender is removed too early, the game may quickly become out of reach for the trailing team.
  • Tired Players: When a team pulls the goalie, the players remaining on the ice often become tired more quickly. This can lead to mistakes and turnovers that the opposing team can take advantage of.
  • Lack of Defensive Coverage: With an extra player on the ice, there is a risk of leaving defensive gaps or making poor positional choices. Additionally, if the other team gains possession of the puck in their own zone, they have a better chance of scoring an undefended goal.

How Pulling the Goalie Can Impact the Outcome of the Game

The decision to pull the goalie can significantly impact the outcome of the game. According to statistics, pulling the goaltender increases the probability of a win by about 10% compared to keeping the goaltender in net during the final minutes of the game.

“Pulling the goalie is one of those things where sometimes it works well and other times it doesn’t… It’s a real dangerous thing — as we’ve been guilty of both having success with it and getting scored on.” -Red Wings head coach Jeff Blashill

The choice to pull the goalie depends on many factors such as the score, time remaining, and overall strategy of the team. Coaches must always consider the risks and rewards before making this high-pressure decision.

Answering the question “why do they pull the goalie?” requires careful consideration of the potential benefits and risks involved. While removing the goaltender gives the trailing team a better chance at winning, it also leaves them vulnerable to easy goals and increased fatigue. In the end, only the coach can determine whether or not this high-risk strategy is worth pursuing.

The Psychology of Pulling the Goalie: How It Affects Players and Fans

Pulling the goalie is a critical decision made by hockey coaches in the dying minutes of a game. The move is often met with mixed feelings from both players and fans alike. While it can sometimes lead to losing the game, it is also one of the most decisive strategies to make up for lost points or force an overtime win. So why do they pull the goalie in hockey? In this article, we will explore the psychological impact of pulling the goalie on players and how fans react to it.

The Emotional Impact on Players

Coaches face huge pressure when making the decision to pull the goalie as their move could either pay off magnificently or backfire horribly. For players, who are already fatigued after playing 60 minutes, having to deal with the sudden shift in dynamic can be overwhelming. As soon as the coach gives the signal, priorities change – offense becomes everything and defense takes a back seat.

This decision requires quick adjustments, mental toughness, and teamwork to execute effectively. Players have to find a way to quickly adapt to being shorthanded while still attempting scoring goals against a team that now has more men on the ice than them. A mistake at this point could cost the team the entire game. As such, pulling the goalie comes down to knowing your team’s strengths and weaknesses, making quick decisions about substitutions, and working hard to maximize opportunities.

The Reaction of Fans to Pulling the Goalie

Fans are passionate about their favorite teams and games. However, they are not always well aware of the strategic importance of specific plays like pulling the goalie. Some may view the tactic as too risky and criticize the coach for employing it while others understand its significance and support the decision fully.

During a game, emotions run high for fans from start to finish. With the game on the line and the coach deciding to pull the goalie, anxiety levels can be magnified tenfold. The roar of the crowd increases as they implore their team to score before time runs out, creating an electric atmosphere in the stadium and added pressure on the players to perform under the scrutiny of thousands of eyes.

How Pulling the Goalie Can Change the Dynamics of the Game

The strategic decision to pull the goalie is one that fundamentally changes up everything about the way a team plays. When coaches call for the move, we see lines being shuffled around, with top scorers, playmakers, and fast skaters coming on ice while stay-at-home defenders sit on the bench. In essence, pulling the goalie shifts priorities – it’s no longer about defense but centering efforts on offense alone. This fact tells us why coaches only use this tactic when their teams are trailing as they only have something to gain and nothing to lose.

When a goalie is pulled, there is also a mental shift amongst both teams, especially for those who haven’t encountered a last-minute goal surge by their opponent. Defensemen must ensure that puck possession remains with their team at all times while forwards launch quick counterattacks against the other team. It’s a unique challenge and requires great teamwork and coordination to implement effectively.

The Importance of Mental Toughness in Making the Decision to Pull the Goalie

Mental toughness is a critical trait required to execute the decision without buckling under pressure. A good hockey player understands that the outcome of the game might hinge on such nuanced decisions, which calls for calmness and a pragmatic approach. Team captains can provide critical guidance during these moments by keeping teammates level-headed and pushing them to find new levels of determination. Coaches, too, must be unwavering in their decision-making, having already decided which players will substitute and taking into consideration the strengths of the other team.

“During a high-pressure situation like calling for goalie pull, discipline and grit are paramount. Listen to your coaches’ instructions carefully and work together as teammates towards a common goal.” – Sidney Crosby

Pulling the goalie is not just about scrambling to win a game; it’s about creating new opportunities for attack while still holding off any last-ditch efforts by the opponents. The call to action can be empowering and offer an adrenaline rush for both players and fans, but people need to understand that there’s also a risk involved. Good teams know when to employ such tactics based on the knowledge of their team members and the strength of the playing lineup. Ultimately, the decision must involve the combined skills of the coaches, captains, and entire team to make it effective.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do teams pull the goalie in hockey?

Teams pull the goalie in hockey when they are losing by one goal or more and there is little time left in the game. By removing the goalie, the team gains an extra skater on the ice, increasing their chances of scoring a goal and tying the game. This is a high-risk, high-reward strategy that can make or break a team’s chances of winning.

What is the strategy behind pulling the goalie?

The strategy behind pulling the goalie is to increase a team’s offensive power and give them a better chance of scoring a goal. By removing the goalie, the team gains an extra skater on the ice, creating more space and opportunities for scoring chances. However, this strategy also leaves the goal undefended, making it a high-risk move that can lead to an empty-net goal by the opposing team.

When is the best time to pull the goalie in a game?

The best time to pull the goalie in a game is when a team is losing by one goal or more and there is little time left in the game. Typically, coaches will wait until there is less than two minutes remaining in the game before pulling the goalie. However, this decision ultimately depends on the coach’s assessment of the game’s flow and their team’s chances of scoring a goal.

What are the risks of pulling the goalie too early or too late?

The risks of pulling the goalie too early or too late are significant. Pulling the goalie too early can give the opposing team an easy empty-net goal, essentially sealing the game. Pulling the goalie too late can leave the team with too little time to score the necessary goals to tie or win the game. It’s a delicate decision that coaches must make based on their team’s abilities and the game’s circumstances.

How often do teams successfully score with the extra attacker after pulling the goalie?

Teams have varying success rates when they pull their goalie in hockey. On average, teams score with the extra attacker about 20% of the time. However, this success rate can vary widely depending on the teams involved, the game’s circumstances, and the skill of the players on the ice. It’s a high-risk, high-reward strategy that can sometimes pay off in a big way.

Craving More Content?

Ice Hockey Central